Nominations Clarification 6 + Tagset Cleanup

[genfreeformmod]

Links: Rules (Nominations - Sign Ups - Assignments - FAQ) | AO3 Collection | Tagset

Quick important note: We realized yesterday that we've had anon commenting off, but it's on now! Sorry about that.

Hi, thanks for a great nomination period! We have an amazing tagset and we're so excited to open sign ups soon. First there's some housekeeping to do. Below are two sections containing first items we're still seeking feedback on (by which we mean: they are still in tag limbo) and second is a section for tags we have rejected or moved in order to move this along quicker.

In addition, please let us know if while browsing the tagset you see:

• Duplicate freeforms — we will be extremely sparse with merging similar freeforms but maybe we approved, like, "Arranged Platonic Marriage" and "Platonic Arranged Marriage"? Also, you're encouraged to use the comments below to ask what tags mean or what the difference between two similar tags is.
• Wandering tags —- sometimes tags get into places they're not supposed to be! Let us know so we can evacuate them.
• Duplicate relationship/character tags — we would like to know about these but will not necessarily "correct" them as we know that in some cases they're deliberate.
• Typos and other goofs — We can't fix capitalization (much to our despair) but if something is spelled wrong or something let us know!

Thank you very much to everyone who's already pointed out errors! Some of them we have not gotten around to fixing/replying to yet but we really appreciate it.

SEEKING FEEDBACK

Fandoms/Relationships

Les Misérables - All Media Types

• We won't accept AMT without hearing from you but we will let these tags hang around in limbo because re-adding them would be a pain.
• Please comment below: are you sure you need AMT? If you prefer any one version over any other version we HIGHLY suggest you let us know so we can change these noms to reflect that, as requests under this tag could be filled by a fanwork based on literally any Les Mis adaptation.

Tomb Raider & Related Fandoms

• This is basically an All Media Types tag and we don't know much at all about Tomb Raider…
• ...so like Les Mis above, nominator, please stop by and tell us you're sure you don't want to specify the video games or one of the movies.

Steins;Gate

• Future Gadget Lab (Steins Gate) — We goofed and accepted this briefly but, um, it seems to be a location? It has been removed but if the nominator tells us what they actually wanted we'll add whatever that is into the tagset for them.

Freeforms

• Underage sex work - dubiously consensual as the character had no other way to stay alive — Thank you for clarifying this, nominator! Unfortunately, this version of the tag isn't gen enough for us because it's pretty directly requesting that the character engage in sexual relations with one or more people in the fanwork you'd be requesting, and obviously that's not gen. Maybe we could rephrase this tag to put the focus on a gen interaction that comes as a result of the sex work! But as it stands we will not accept this tag,
• Tony Stark Acting as Peter Parker's Parental Figure — We're pretty sure this should be "MCU: Tony Stark Acting as Peter Parker's Parental Figure" but just checking! You mean MCU, right?
• Omega Jace Wayland — What fandom is this?

EXECUTIVE DECISIONS

In order to get things moving we've rejected, or accepted+moved some tags because we asked for nominator input previously and didn't get it. If you are the nominator and we goofed or you would like to rephrase something we rejected or whatever, please comment below.

Fandoms/Relationships

Crossover Fandom

• Jane Marple (Marple series) & Hercule Poirot (Poirot series), Jane Marple (Marple) & Maud Silver (Miss Silver Mysteries - Patricia Wentworth), Jane Marple (Marple) & Nancy Drew (Nancy Drew - Carolyn Keene) — Accepted as-is on the basis that you probably know what you're about.
• Mary Poppins & the Thirteenth Doctor (Doctor Who) — Accepted as "Mary Poppins (Any Version) & the Thirteenth Doctor (Doctor Who)"

Spider-Man (Tom Holland Movies)

• Jessica Jones & Michelle Jones, Jessica Jones & Peter Parker — We put these in "Marvel Cinematic Universe"

The Avengers (Marvel Movies)

• Steve Rogers & Natasha Romanoff - We we put this in "Marvel Cinematic Universe"

DC (Comics)

• Pamela Isley & Harleen Quinzel, Pamela Isley & Selina Kyle & Harleen Quinzel, Selina Kyle & Harleen Quinzel — Rejected because they're not disambiguated and we don't know enough to guess what you might want.

Marvel (Comics)

• Stephen Strange & Victor Von Doom, Tony Stark & Victor Von Doom — We aren't accepting this fandom so we guessed and put them in "Marvel 616"

Freeforms

• Childhood Sweethearts — Rejected; not gen enough.
• Enemies With Benefits — Rejected; not gen enough.
• Take Your Fandom to Work Day —Rejected; too confusing/ambiguous.
• what do you mean "just" friends? — Rejected; too confusing/ambiguous.
• Universe Travel where social status is reversed — Rejected; too confusing/ambiguous.
• This Will Make An Excellent Movie — Rejected; too confusing/ambiguous.

We will accept late clarification/rephrasing of rejected freeforms and relationships during the tag clean up period, especially since we goofed with checking that anonymous commenting was on. Time permitting, we may also add in extra tags if anyone's suddenly realized they forgot to nom something. In order to make it easier for us, please give us your lists in this format:

• Freeforms — Freeform one,freeform two,freeform three
• Relationships/characters — Fandom one,relationship,relationship,solo: character
  Fandom two,relationship,relationship,relationship

Please follow the nomination guidelines. If you don't disambiguate, use "Solo:" or "Group:", capitalize character names, etc, then it will be too much work for us and we won't add your tags for you because we won't have time.

Comments

[reconditarmonia]

Hi! If you're still accepting nominations, can I add -

- Learning From an Enemy

- Avatar: The Legend of Korra
--Group: Korra & Kuvira
--Group: Korra & Zaheer

[genfreeformmod]

Hi! I will add the freeform no problem. For the fandom and relationships, please review the nomination guidelines and the above post about how we want extra noms given to us in comments on this post.

[reconditarmonia]

Sorry to misunderstand, is this better?

Relationships/characters — Avatar: The Legend of Korra,Group: Korra & Kuvira (LOK),Group: Korra & Zaheer (LOK)

Thank you!

[genfreeformmod]

Close enough. Done!